John Dutton (Kevin Costner) Image via Paramount Network. Dan Jenkins 47 Episodes 2022. While Ned and Chance's backstory remains a mystery, we only hope we can learn more about these Duttons in the upcoming season of Yellowstone. Its been a wild week for everyone, which is part of why Im worried that. Yellowstone Season 2. The Dutton family tree is pretty complicated, but it doesn't have to be. Gil Birmingham. Both couples have certainly shown the kind of passion that leads to baby-making. Why Trust Us? Our best guest is she's a second child to Jack and Elizabeth, although Spencer and Alex could have also given birth to a daughter. Additionally, I would have said the sheriffs decision to send Beth to jail was a dumb move, given whatever Dutton-originated firestorm is coming his way, but it was literally the only move he could have made with all those people around, particularly the woman threatening to press charges on Beth. Up until then she's only described as Margaret Dutton's (Faith Hill) sister-in-law, but since her last name is Dutton, she must be kin to James and Jacob. Fans who have re-watched the show (or had a rather thorough first watch) may remember hearing of Chance and Ned Dutton. The most popular theories are that Ned Dutton is likely a nephew of James Dutton from 1883. So whatever power Jamie thinks he has going into any future conversations with Sarah has a foundation of nothing sprinkled with imagination, which does not bode well for John, Beth and the ranch. But what about guys like Lloyd, Rip, and Walker? Yellowstone continues to represent a citizens-before-government attitude, and it would be bonkers if life imitated art in just such a way, at least when it comes to elements that are truly expendable. Our readers support us. chance dutton headstone yellowstone. Before knowing Jamie was adopted, I had a suspicion for some time that Lee was not John 3s son, but instead a son Chance or Neds son. And theres no denying that her pleasure waves of success through such brilliant badassery went fully tidal by the time aggravated assaults entered the picture. In accord with Johns speech at the Stockmans Dinner, Ned and Chance would have likely died sometime after 1886. Theres still time for that, though. The second is John Dutton's (Costner) father, played by Dabney Coleman in Yellowstone. Danny Huston. Perhaps this is one of the show's best-kept secrets and we'll learn more in the episodes to come. The first scene in Paramount Network's Yellowstone shows Kevin Costner's John Dutton emerge from a steaming car crash, approach a dying horse, apologize to it, then shoot it in the head. Jacob is James' older brother, something Ford confirmed to Taste of Country. Paramount Network's ' Yellowstone ' follows the Duttons and the many threats they face while protecting their ancestral Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. I cant tell just yet whether or not Rainwater made terrible choices by not shutting up that protester and not standing up to Angela Blue Thunder when she threatened him. Finally, we get to the teal generation, which is Tate Dutton, his late baby brother John and by way of adoption Jamie Dutton's son, whose name isn't 100 percent clear. Click here to refresh the page. ?,," one fan asked. I expect the phrase hitting rock bottom to be replaced by hitting Jamie Dutton by the finale. We won't say more, as we don't want to spoil it for those who've not yet watched. 4.10 Grass on the Streets and Weeds on the Rooftops, 5.06 Cigarettes, Whiskey, a Meadow and You. During the funeral of Lee Dutton, two graves are seen in the background. Im not worried that Beth would do anything violent, considering shed be so willing to have a child herself if it was possible, but the fact that its not possible is obviously her fuel here. But lets not pretend here; Rip totally sparked a wholly separate fuse within Beth when he denied her night-out intentions in front of the whole bunkhouse, giving her that much more reason to get white girl wasted. Like the dialogue noted above, this line could be taken two different ways. While we dont know who Ned and Chances parents are, some Reddit users suspect that they were the eldest sons of Margaret and James that died at a young age. Is there perhaps a separate graveyard where all of the loyal hands are laid to rest? (Seriously, Beth used Summer as prison-bound bait in Season 4, but I guess her environmental knowledge is just that good?) (As well as questions about where Josh Lucas fan-rousing younger John Dutton was this week. He is the great grandfather of Yellowstone's John Dutton ( Kevin Costner) and the son of 1883's James Dutton ( Tim. As a young boy, Rip walked in on his stepdad murdering his mother. Similarly, Chance Dutton could also be a nephew of James or related to other members of the Dutton family tree. So naturally, we had to track it down. Chance Dutton's gravestone as shown in John Dutton's memory When 1883 first introduced Elsa Dutton to be something of a polar opposite to Beth, a lot of fans likely envisioned an impossible reality where the two characters could meet up and shoot the. First appearance Yellowstone is full of familial mysteries. One has to make certain assumptions at this point. To me, it very much looks as if that second letter is an O and not an A, which makes it then slightly easier to imagine an H and an N in the following spots. It also reveals Peter Dutton as John Dutton's (Costner) brother, a boy who died as a baby (revealed during Season 5 of Yellowstone). Who Were Ned and Chance Dutton? By the Redditors description, its safe to assume that Chance is of the same era, as well. Tall Drink of Water tested that specific hypothesis in certain ways, with several of the main characters making truly questionable choices that, appropriately enough, felt far more scripted for TV than authentic actions these people would be making. John Dutton takes a close look of a photo of his wife and three children; Lee is noticeably missing. Shes really digging into her diet-psychotic need for enemies there, and doing shit like making Jamie call her maam is either going to lead to uncomfortable sexual chemistry or its going to make him recoil to the point of getting vengeful. It'd be a crime to start with anyone other than the patriarch of the Dutton clan, whom the story has as the owner of the largest ranch . Considering viewers last saw Kayce and Monica seemingly on the skids when Season 4 ended, it was quite the baffling reveal to see her expecting to the point of bursting at the abdominal seams. It first aired on June 20, 2018. Below is our look at Yellowstone's third episode, "Tall Drink of Water," comprising the worst character decisions made throughout. And since Market Equities is now at its most desperate point of this fight, Jamie will have to wisen up immediately to make it out of this without two cockstrong and powerful women wanting to bury him alive. We've marked that as speculation since it's not been confirmed. We can't justify another generation at this point. (Funnily enough, a particular females sexual activities were at the heart of both fights.) .css-lwn4i5{display:block;font-family:Neutra,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.01rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;text-align:center;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-lwn4i5:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}Christina Hendricks Flaunts Strong Legs In IG Pics, Adam Sandler's Wife Jackie Shuts Down Red Carpet, Sam Heughan Posted a Heartbreaking IG on Season 7, See Riley Keough's Tribute to Lisa Marie Presley, Savannah Guthrie Wore a See-Through Lace Dress. Article ID: 21661. James Dutton (Tim McGraw), the lead of 1883 is John. However, the date on Neds grave could easily be retconned to his birthday, making the character a nephew of James Dutton. But at the least, theres a chance we may learn more about Chance and Ned, the forgotten Duttons, in future episodes of either Yellowstone or 1883. "Are you coming back to Yellowstone as a flashback!?? I think theyre related to John Dutton 2 (Kevin Cs fathrr character). Up to this point, Jamies son with Christina Lil Jamie Dueces is what Id like to call him doesnt seem to have had a rough life yet, despite unwittingly losing his grandfather in a similar way to his grandmother. All the more bawl-worthy was learning what theyd named the boy, as it presumably makes him the fourth-generation John, cementing that part of the family legacy not-so-coincidentally around the point when Paramount Network aired the first teaser for 1923, the upcoming prequel with Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren. Now a happily married woman who is more than pleased to present herself as such, Beth remains conflicted over her past with Rip. Fans of the first "Yellowstone" origin series "1883" might recall that Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) was married to Comanche tribesman Sam (Martin Sensmeier), who she met while heading toward Montana . Both headstones and the style and size of the font of the engravings were the same, as well was the age and wear of the stone. Fixed: Release in which this issue/RFE has been fixed.The release containing this fix may be available for download as an Early Access Release or a General Availability Release. Joshua Lucas. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. John said "Since 1886, every Dutton who died is buried 300 yards from my back porch. Moreover, the creator has made the drama full of mystery. But I could not see the date on Chances because the prairie grass obscured it. Lee was also a Montana Livestock Association Agent. How would we know? Spoilers below for Yellowstones latest episode, Watch Em Ride Away, so be warned if you havent yet watched the whole shebang. To end things on someone whose past we know nothing about, I harbor a healthy worry that. Along the way, some have picked up a major error surrounding Lee Dutton's (Dave Annable) storyline. From fleeing a life of poverty to owning the largest cattle ranch in Montana, the family has come a long way. And it wont, because it cant, because hes Jamie. Fans who have re-watched the show (or had a rather thorough first watch) may remember hearing of Chance and Ned Dutton. By all means, all the power to her for taking the initiative to start a conversation with Rip, as hes the epitome of a cowboy bar catch. [1] Chance's birth date and the date of his death are unknown. Maybe just one week? However, the relationship between Ned and Chance Dutton or their relationship with other members of the Dutton family remains unclear. I doubt it, but I sorta hope it happens, and that we get a cage fight by the end of Season 5. As Redditor DrBCraft asks fellow fans: Forgive me if this is obvious or has been addressed before somewhere on this subreddit But do we know who Chance and Ned Dutton are? Also, many speculate that Chance Dutton is either another of James Duttons nephews, or the brother of John Dutton III. Appearances Season 1 Daybreak (episode 1) - Mentioned References Season 1, episode 1: Daybreak Others like you also viewed The only reasonable explanation for Ned and Chance is that they were Jacob and Cara's (Helen Mirren) children, and they died before 1923. The names of Ned and Chance Dutton are never spoken on the screen. But how long can that line of thinking last? (For everyone whos been waiting on Monty Python references in a Yellowstone story, we made it!) They make it a point to see it," the fan wrote. If only shed embraced logic earlier. Speaking of Beth and bottles, Im also pretty worried that. Deceased Chance Dutton is one of the family members in Yellowstone who has picked the interest of viewers. A look into details provided in the United States instalment will be on. But considering their conversation largely revolves around John Dutton as an entity, could just as easily have been implying he was the first in the family to don that name. The Duttons protect their land generation after generation because it is the resting place of their ancestors. Photo credit: Paramount Network. This 'Yellowstone' Flashback Could Be a Clue That Elsa Dutton is Pregnant on '1883' Newsweek proposed this theory earlier today. While the builder was only horribly injured and not dead by the episodes end, I cant help but think Rip and Rowdys reign of terror defending Johns land gets far worse. "She takes it down and Jamie puts it back up. I think Chance & Ned are the eldest boys of James and Margaret Dutton. I cant lie, I get as big of a vicarious kick as the next person out of watching Governor John Dutton trimming the executive fat from his office, proving Beths impulse control issues are wholly genetic. Others theorize that Ned and Chance could have been nephews to James who traveled to the ranch after it was established. John 2 mentions missing his dead son when we get that JD 2 and 3 flashback scene in season 2. So he likely doesnt feel the same what if? pangs that Beth does, but the dying cattle plotline combined with heightened pressures to send Rips subconscious into the past as well, though for a more disturbing reason. In the time since, we've seen glimmers of Lee here and there, mainly in flashback scenes with Kayce (Luke Grimes), Jamie (Wes Bentley) and Beth (Kelly Reilly). Elsa is buried on this land, and the Duttons settle on the property. Grammer Roommate Pilot the culprit was a person in a run-down van, popping out the back to a. So lets take a closer look at what may or may not have been shown. Some fans have a far-fetched theory that Lee was the person behind the camera, but other have chalked it up to "sloppy writing.". He's a young man who helped his father and great-uncle (Jacob Dutton) on their relatively new land. And, to repeat myself from an above comment, the headstones did not look that old; they weren't worn down or covered with lichen. But not everyones skills can automatically vault to State Government level on a whim just because John brings them in, from Beth and her law-skirting maneuvers to Piper Perabos returning recruit Summer. The first season continues with episode two titled "Kill the Messenger" airing on June 27 . Elsa Dutton. This post may contain affiliate links. Granted, she didnt seem like the kind of woman who would pull up her roots to escape an emotionally difficult situation, but its hard to put oneself into the shoes of anyone whos gone through such particular tragedies. Ill add it to the list with the dinosaur bones! Yellowstone's first episode weaves. To the episodes credit, I suppose, Sheridan & Co. telegraphed these scenes to set off massive alarm bells within viewers and buffer the shock of the tragedy to come. For as much as Yellowstones flashbacks appear to be setting up some emotional catalysts for certain characters, you wouldnt know it by looking at Rips face throughout Season 5 so far. Also, see our Dutton family tree infographic to help you understand the Dutton family lineage we discuss. But no, theres just a little too much going on behind her eyes to squash all suspicions outright. Where her main motivation should be to keep out of any trouble that could draw negative attention to Johns atypical maneuvers as Montanas governor, her actual mission statement appears to be Gotcha, bitch. She couldnt just let sleeping (with her father) dogs lie by giving Summer her space, not that Piper Perabos homebound activist made her face any less punchable by railing on Gators dinner spread. Wes Bentley- "Jamie Dutton" Later, viewers learn that Johns wife, Evelyn Dutton, and father, John Dutton Jr, are also buried on the ranch following their deaths. Post author: Post published: 8 juin 2022 Post category: 5 letter word with most consonants Post comments: demos grilled chicken recipe demos grilled chicken recipe If the second John Sr. (Coleman) were Spencer's boy, that would wipe out a full generation and only make Costner's John a fourth-generation rancher. So I guess she put all of that energy into the motivation to brawl, even though she should have known that using any kind of weapon in the process would lead to bigger repercussions. No reason to start with anything else here, since Beths drunken and petty attack, along with its aftermath, capped off the episode. Fans met days of Dutton past first with Yellowstone prequel 1883, and now we're being introduced to the next lineage in the latest installment of the story: 1923.The tale of Cara and Jacob . Since 1886, every Dutton who died is buried 300 yards from my back porch. So just as Jamie talked Hailey into not pressing charges, thus getting Beth out of jail, he theoretically could just as easily find ways to put her and/or others into jail. Itd be one thing if these markers featured lowercase letters that would account for the A being curved, but the AGED carving below proves thats not the case. Why did Kayce Dutton leave Yellowstone? Paramount Network's 'Yellowstone' is the story of the Dutton family, who own the largest ranch in America. I guess they could revisit this plot point, but it seems like another loose thread well likely never get a resolution to. Anyone entering John Duttons inner circle needs around 15 rounds of vetting, but she came out of nowhere as far as viewers are concerned, and is working with John out of duty, as opposed to out of loyalty. So lets lace up our gloves and step into the ring that is the Duttons front yard. In the series premiere episode of Yellowstone, viewers see the death of John Duttons eldest son, Lee Dutton. Hell, it might not be unintentional at all, given how betrayed he feels, but hell no doubt believe that itll all work out in his favor. Press J to jump to the feed. On Ned's I could make out "March 16, 186__". Thus, it is evident that the Duttons hold a sentimental value to their land. Whatever it was, shes probably not thinking much straighter now, and while it may be an ill-advised move to press charges against any Duttons without a monolithic corporation behind her, its still the only logical one. A new theory suggests it could be Thomas Rainwater's assistant, Mo. Through his attorney, the Oscar winner denied reports that he is responsible for delays in filming the rest of season 5. However, they are present in spirit during the series premiere episode. Obviously Im not going to sit here and act like Kayces motivation to save his marriage wasnt an honorable enough reason to decide to step away from his leadership position as the Livestock Commissioner. Truly, I may not have been so eager to question her stone in particular had it not been for that timely close-up that soon followed Monica saying to Summer: If your goal is knowing John Dutton, then this is exactly where you should be. That's no good. This would point to Ned and Chance Dutton being brothers of 1883s John Dutton Sr (grandfather of Kevin Costners John). Im pretty sure theres a rule somewhere that says: If Rip smiles three times before the rooster crows, start planning your goodbyes. But does that mean hell take a mental plunge after Beth divulges her aforementioned traumas, or could it be something more devastating? Yellowstone kicked off the fourth episode of Season 5 with Beth in jail, having spent a night (and then far too much of the rest of the day) wearing her bar fight attire from the memorable evening prior. Even with the release of 1883, there is still a lot we dont know about this powerful family. The third episode of 1923 (and simple math) makes it clear these men are not the same man. Ned's headstone says 3/16/1863 so if he is buried there, he died after 1886 according to John's speech at the Stockman's Dinner. ), Below are the five biggest concerns Im bouncing between following Episode 504 (with a geotracker collar around my leg to fool Fish & Wildlife officers), starting with everyones favorite rabble-rouser. Surdo in Provincia di Cosenza (Calabria) with it's 1,659 citizens is a city in Italy about 262 mi (or 422 km) south-east of Rome, the country's capital city. But will Sarah have what it takes to convincingly turn Jamie against the fam, given all the evidential fuel that Beth has on him? Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, At this point, Im 100% wondering if Faith Hills Margaret Dutton will be featured once more in another prequel season that explores her life as a widow, with or without her children in her stead. Once authorities with a Dutton-hating stick up their rear start looking into things happening at the Y, is there ever a point when they'd stop looking? . Cole Hauser. My theory at the time was that Chance/ Ned suffered a similar death to Lee and it was going to be a plot point in S1. During Ep. John Dutton, played by Kevin Costner, is the patriarch of a ranching family and owner of the largest ranch in the U.S. Dutton's Yellowstone Ranch borders the national park of the same name, a. 1. Daybreak is the first episode of the first season of Yellowstone. Resolved: Release in which this issue/RFE has been resolved. Not that hed be the first politician to do such things, and we know that his reasoning for doing so is to surround himself with those who would protect the ranch. Whats more, Taylor Sheridans writing also skews intentionally vague in a way that raises questions about whether or not the man weve known to be James Dutton is actually the first John. The opening episode of 1923 reveals that Jacob rushed to save the family upon James' death. But in an episode where the protagonists made rash actions that may not have been so smart, I cant knock the guy for thinking before leaping. Elizabeth Dutton Formally known as Elizabeth Strafford (Michelle Randolph), this character was set to marry Jack Dutton in 1923. Jack Dutton Jack (Darren Mann) is the son of John Sr. and Emma in 1923. Characters Lee Dutton is a ranch hand of the Yellowstone Ranch and the oldest son of ranch owner John Dutton and his wife Evelyn Dutton. About halfway through their meal, John's . Anytime Jamie Dutton thinks hes the most important mover and shaker in the room, Yellowstone fans know hes probably wrong, but its at least a change of pace from the defeated servant vibe he has anytime Beth is around. They died prior and what could have initiated the move to Montana. However, John Dutton III from Yellowstone never talks about a lost or deceased brother. The Dutton Family are the owners of Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, the largest ranch in the United States and still growing. In order to survive, he had to kill his stepdad by hitting him in the head with a frying pan. Another fan pointed out that the photos shown appear to have some greater significance, which means there may be more to Lee's absence than meets the eye. And in that respect, I cant tell if I truly buy into Beths 15 feet tall and bulletproof attitude dulling her comprehension that breaking the law in public actively goes against the instincts of any governors chief of staff. From. Meanwhile, James daughter, Elsa Dutton, is gravely injured and near death. The rest of the video (and what follows here) is the more detailed explanation. During the very first episode of Yellowstone, we learn that John Dutton ( Kevin Costner) actually had four children, but his oldest son, Lee, was shot and killed during a failed mission to take. But any attempts to feel joy about such miracles were clearly destined for doom as soon as Monica confidently declared she would drive herself to the hospital. As seen in the preview for Episode 6 and as hinted at by the general ominous vibe tied to virtually everyone leaving the ranch for two full days something big and not-so-great is going to go down while John & Co. are out and about. New York, While they eagerly wait for Paramount Network to announce the season 4 premiere date, fans are killing time by digging deeper into the Dutton family's past, present and future. It was founded by James Dutton, a Tennessee farmer who relocated with his family from Fort Worth, Texas to Montana during the Western Expansion, while the caravan was making the trek to Oregon. That math only works if this John Sr. (Coleman) is great-grandson to James (McGraw). To fully know this bloodline of Johns, she must first familiarize yourself with the first woman who birthed one (that we know of, obviously). With the same engraving font and similar wear on Chances gravestone, many assume the two died around the same time. 20 Best Modern Western TV Shows for Cowboy Lovers, You Can Spend the Night at the Iconic Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, James sister Claire before she shot herself she said she had lost all 7 of her children His brother Jacob and his wife Cars had no children Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. There was a problem. which phrase signals a contrast between ideals about marriage 304-539-8172; one level homes in clemmons, nc casadeglo3@gmail.com It is likely that series co-creator Taylor Sheridan had not crafted the Dutton familys backstory while the first episode was filmed, explaining the lack of explanation about the graves of the two forgotten Duttons. One is dedicated to Ned Dutton, while the other has Chances name written on it. Read More:Does Jamie Die in Yellowstone? We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. After all, even though we know her sons John and Spencer will be part of 1923s storyline, we dont really know if they remained on the ranch for all the years from childhood to adulthood. But will having a second knockdown, drag-out fight at least be enough to curb those violent urges for at least a few weeks of Johns governorship? Interestingly, Ned Duttons grave is marked with the year 1863. From my great-great-grandfather to my wife and my oldest son," said John. Hopefully it just means Rip starts telling Dad jokes more often. We might have to wait for 1923s debut to get the answers to one or more of these questions, or we might go to our own graves without gaining more insight into any of them. Aside from promoting the show's Memorial Day marathon, the last time the actor posted about Yellowstone was on the day of the season 2 premiere, joking he's "not sure how the show made it to a season 2 with its biggest name being offed in the first episode.". "Since 1886, every Dutton who died is buried 300 yards from my back porch. Among them are Ned and Chance Dutton, whose lives and connections to John Dutton (Kevin Costner) remain unknown. There are several names on the headstones that. If Kayce thinks that working for Rainwater will somehow be way less complicated than what he was doing before, hes likely in for a rude awakening. He worked the Yellowstone land alongside . For one, Ryan noted that wolves weren't responsible for killing anything, only for Rip to sweep those suspicions under some horse manure. It made me wonder if they were buried at the same time. I didnt see your post, but I had all the same thoughts and even tried to see what the date was! But in the way that there will always be LEGO-esque building blocks standing alongside the monolith, it stands to reason there are other people in the world who share similar outlooks and playbooks with Kelly Reillys stinger-covered queen bee. John Dutton III, Chance Dutton John mentions Chance during the burial of Lee in the Yellowstone pilot. Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Personally, I think acting out physically against others is the only way Beth is able to side-shift her eagerness to maul Jamie. Let's recap: In true Dutton fashion, the family John, Beth, and Kayce ended the episode with dinner at the ranch house. John Dutton Sr. is the nephew and right hand man of Jacob Dutton. It appears as if Rip and Kai Casters new character Rowdy were tasked by John with giving a contractor, Elijah Mahars Dick Weller, a taste of his own medicine (poison) to stop the chemicals from being used near his land. Let's break it down. If you've followed the Dutton family's story since season one, you may be wondering if Yellowstone is based on a true story and if the Duttons or their ranch are real.. Yellowstone, which premiered in June 2018, is a Western drama series that follows the Dutton family, the owners of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranchalso known as the Yellowstonethe largest ranch in Montana. If you are wondering why the Duttons are buried on their ranch in Yellowstone, here is everything you need to know! She also has a soft spot for feel-good TV, so you can catch her writing about popular shows like Virgin River, Sweet Magnolias, Hallmark Channels When Calls the Heart and more. Perhaps more attention will be put on the tragedy when they bury him on the ranch, assuming John is as cool with it as Kayce assumes. Jamie is only one source of Beths recent ire (even though hes probably still tied to others), as shes also been spending quite a bit of time in flashback mode while working out some mental knots tied to her past with Rip and Rowdy. The scene takes place in the family graveyard at the beginning of the series. Clearly, the woman weve come to know as Sarah Atwood isnt above doing whatever it takes in any situation. However, John Dutton III from Yellowstone never talks about a lost or deceased brother. Therefore, his death would predate Elsas death and the Dutton familys arrival in Paradise Valley. That can be a frustratingly hard behavior to curb, too, and Beth may be too far along in her bottle-bludgeoning ways to get ahead of them, which probably isnt good for John or the ranch. ---- But unless Margaret (Faith Hill) and James Dutton (Tim McGraw) have two more boys well into their 50s, this isnt the case (which wouldve been highly unlikely in the 19th century at their age).